Table of contents:
Video: Wigner's friend paradox: is there an objective reality?
2024 Author: Seth Attwood | [email protected]. Last modified: 2023-12-16 15:55
What is reality? And who can answer this question? Last year, scientists at Heriot-Watt University in Scotland tested an interesting experiment that suggests objective reality may not exist.
Despite the fact that once this idea was just a theory, now the researchers were able to transfer it to the walls of the university laboratory, and therefore test it. Since in the quantum world measurements from different positions give different results, but at the same time are equally correct, the experiment carried out showed that in the world of quantum physics two people can observe the same event and different results; however, neither of these two events can be perceived as wrong.
In other words, if two people see two different realities, then they cannot agree which one is correct. This paradox is known as "Wigner's friend paradox" and now scientists have experimentally proven it.
Quantum mechanics is a branch of theoretical physics that describes the basic properties and behavior of atoms, ions, molecules, electrons, photons, condensed matter, and other elementary particles.
Wigner's friend paradox
In 1961, Nobel Prize laureate in physics Eugene Wigner seriously questioned what objective reality is. The scientist proposed one of the strangest experiments in quantum mechanics, which involved the idea that two people could observe two different realities and neither of them would technically be wrong. But how?
In a thought experiment called Wigner's friend paradox, two scientists in a laboratory study a photon, the smallest quantitative unit of light. It is noteworthy that this polarized photon, when measured, can have either horizontal polarization or vertical polarization. But before measurement, according to the laws of quantum mechanics, a photon exists in both polarization states simultaneously - in the so-called superposition.
So, Wigner imagined how his friend in another laboratory measures the state of this photon and remembers the result, while Wigner himself observes from afar. At the same time, Wigner does not have any information about the measurement of his friend, and therefore he is forced to assume that the photon and its measurement are in a superposition of all possible experimental results.
But this is in stark contrast to the point of view of Wigner's friend, who actually measured the polarization of the photon and recorded it! The friend may even call Wigner and tell him that the measurement has been taken (provided that the result is not revealed). Thus, we get two realities, contradicting each other, which casts doubt on the objective status of the facts established by two observers.
It is noteworthy that until 2019 - until the Swedish scientists did the same experiment in the laboratory - Wigner's friend's paradox was purely a thought experiment. Just like the world famous experiment proposed by the Austrian theoretical physicist Edwin Schrödinger.
Schrödinger's cat is a thought experiment describing the absurdity of quantum mechanics. Imagine you have a cat and a box. In the box you put a cat, a radioactive substance and a special mechanism that opens a flask with poison. In the event of the decay of a radioactive atom in a closed box - and this can happen at any moment - the mechanism will open the container with the poison and the cat will die. But you can only find out whether a radioactive atom has decayed or not, you can only look into the box. Up to this point, according to the principles of quantum physics, the cat is both alive and dead, that is, it is in superposition.
Is there no objective reality?
The researchers used six entangled photons to create two alternative realities in the lab. One reality represented Wigner's reality, the other the reality of his friend. Wigner's friend measured the polarization of the photon and saved the result, after which Wigner himself performed an interference measurement to determine if the measurement and the photon were in superposition.
The results obtained by the team of scientists were mixed. It turned out that both realities can coexist, even if they lead to irreconcilable results - just as Eugene Wigner predicted. But can they be reconciled?
The idea that observers can eventually reconcile their measurements of some fundamental reality is based on several assumptions.
First, universal facts do exist and observers can agree on them.
Second, the choices that one observer makes does not affect the choices that other observers make - this assumption physics calls locality. So if there is an objective reality that everyone can agree with, then all these assumptions are true.
But the results of the work of scientists from Heriot-Watt University, published in the journal Science Advances, indicate that objective reality does not exist. In other words, the experiment suggests that one or more assumptions - the idea that there is a reality with which we can agree, the idea that we have free choice, or the idea of locality - must be wrong.
"The scientific method relies on universally agreed facts established by repeated measurements, regardless of who made the observations," the researchers write in their work.
I don’t know about you, but my head is spinning, because the results obtained provide real evidence that, when it comes to the field of quantum physics, there is no such thing as objective reality.
Recommended:
Why are there controversies about the reality of our world?
Twenty years after the release of the first "Matrix", directors are shooting the fourth. During this time, a lot has changed: the Wachowski brothers became sisters, and scientists took the main idea of the film to heart: imagine, many physicists are seriously discussing the theory that our world is just a matrix, and we are digital models in it
Film: The Earth of the Future. But what if we get there, and everything will be there?
Good reason for a Saturday movie show. Post-apocalyptic films come out very often, it seems that Hollywood has already put an end to the future of humanity and now only wonders what will cause the death of billions of people. Does it depend on us what the Earth of the Future will be like?
There were Russians - now there are Ukrainians. The violent history of Ukrainization
The Bolsheviks, who came to power in 1917 on the ruins of the Russian Empire, immediately took the national question under their special control. Following the new ideological formula, according to which tsarist Russia is a prison of peoples, and the Russian people is an oppressor people, the communist leaders began to build a state of workers and peasants on the foundation of a new national policy
Healthy lifestyle - friend, enemy, or what?
The author of the article discusses the ideology of healthy lifestyle that is gaining popularity in modern Russia. Not only the body, but also the spirit should be healthy, which means that constant intellectual development is necessary, which is rarely observed in the advertised fighting
Here it is, proof that there are Jews and there are Jews
Here is evidence that the Jews and the Nazis are the same berry field. Both are geeks, enemies of the human race